Key Takeaways
- Metal roofing costs more upfront but lasts significantly longer than asphalt shingles, often 40 to 70 years compared to 20 to 30.
- Metal roofing performs especially well against this region’s snow load and heavy rain conditions.
- Asphalt shingles remain the more affordable upfront option and are widely available in a broad range of styles and colors.
- Noise during rain, a common concern about metal roofing, is largely addressed through proper installation with solid decking.
Metal and asphalt shingle roofing represent the two most common roofing choices for homes throughout the Asheville area, each carrying different upfront costs, lifespans, and performance characteristics particularly relevant to this region’s mountain climate. This page compares these two materials to help you choose the right option for your specific home and priorities.
Cost comparison
Asphalt shingle roofing typically costs less upfront than metal roofing, making it the more
Lifespan differences
Asphalt shingles typically last 20 to 30 years depending on quality tier and installation, while metal roofing commonly lasts 40 to 70 years or longer with proper installation and maintenance. This significant lifespan difference means a metal roof installed on a new custom home may genuinely never need replacement during the original owner’s time in the home, while an asphalt roof will likely need replacement at least once over a similar ownership period.
Performance in this region’s climate
Metal roofing performs particularly well against the snow load and heavy rain conditions common throughout Western North Carolina’s mountain climate, since its smooth surface sheds snow and water efficiently and its material strength handles the weight of accumulated snow well. Asphalt shingles perform adequately in this climate as well, though they generally show more wear over time from repeated freeze-thaw cycles and UV exposure compared to metal’s greater durability against these same conditions.
Addressing the noise concern
A common concern homeowners raise about metal roofing is noise during rain, and while metal roofs installed directly over minimal decking can indeed transmit more sound than shingles, proper installation over solid roof decking with appropriate insulation largely addresses this concern, bringing interior noise levels much closer to what a shingle roof produces. Discussing installation method specifically with your contractor, rather than assuming metal roofing automatically means a noisy interior, clarifies this consideration for your specific project.
Style and appearance options
Asphalt shingles offer an extremely broad range of colors, styles, and textures, including options designed to mimic the appearance of wood shake or slate roofing at a fraction of those materials’ cost, making it easy to match a wide range of architectural styles. Metal roofing has expanded its own style options significantly in recent years, including standing seam profiles and various colors, though the overall aesthetic tends toward a more distinctly modern or traditional metal-roof look compared to shingle’s ability to closely mimic other traditional materials. Our post on architectural styles for custom homes covers how roofing material choice interacts with different architectural directions, including how farmhouse style frequently pairs with metal roofing specifically.
Considering your home’s specific style
Certain architectural styles pair particularly well with one roofing material over the other based on regional and historical convention, though this is ultimately a matter of preference rather than a strict rule. Farmhouse-style homes frequently feature metal roofing as part of their overall aesthetic identity, while many traditional and craftsman-style homes commonly use asphalt shingles, though either material can work successfully with thoughtful design across various architectural approaches.
Working with a builder to choose the right roofing material
A contractor familiar with both roofing materials’ performance in this region’s specific climate conditions can help you weigh upfront cost against long-term value and match your roofing choice to your home’s overall architectural direction. Start that conversation through the contact page.
Summary
Metal roofing costs more upfront but delivers a significantly longer service life, often 40 to 70 years compared to asphalt shingles’ 20 to 30 years, and performs particularly well against this region’s snow load and heavy rain conditions. Asphalt shingles remain the more affordable initial option with a broader range of style choices, and proper installation largely addresses common concerns about metal roofing noise during rain. The right choice depends on whether you prioritize lower upfront cost or long-term value and durability. Reach out through the contact page to discuss the right roofing material for your home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is metal roofing worth the higher upfront cost?
Often, yes, for homeowners planning to stay in a home long-term. Metal roofing’s 40 to 70 year lifespan compared to asphalt shingle’s 20 to 30 years means it may never need replacement during an owner’s time in the home, changing the cost comparison significantly over a multi-decade timeframe.
Does metal roofing perform better in Western North Carolina’s climate?
Generally, yes. Metal roofing sheds snow and water efficiently and handles accumulated snow weight well, performing particularly well against this region’s mountain climate conditions compared to asphalt shingles, which show more gradual wear from freeze-thaw cycles and UV exposure.
Is metal roofing really noisier during rain?
Less than commonly assumed, when properly installed. Metal roofs installed over solid roof decking with appropriate insulation bring interior noise levels much closer to shingle roofing, addressing the noise concern that comes up frequently in this material comparison.
Which roofing material offers more style options?
Asphalt shingles offer an extremely broad range of colors, styles, and textures, including options mimicking wood shake or slate at lower cost. Metal roofing has expanded its style options significantly but tends toward a more distinctly modern or traditional metal-roof aesthetic.
Does architectural style affect which roofing material I should choose?
It can influence the decision, since farmhouse-style homes frequently feature metal roofing as part of their aesthetic identity, while traditional and craftsman-style homes commonly use asphalt shingles, though either material can work successfully with thoughtful design.
